Showing posts with label Musings. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Musings. Show all posts

Saturday, February 22, 2020

Wasatch Front Water, Part 1: Experimentation and Finding Focus

This is the first post in (what should be) a series of posts about my latest map, That the Desert May Blossom as the Rose. Today I'm introducing the map and reviewing the background and inspiration behind it. In the future I'll write a little bit more about the techniques I used to realize different ideas and messages in the map.

Click here for a larger, compressed-quality image

Experimentation
About a year ago, right after fixing my skymodel implementation, I started exploring different options for a map of the Wasatch Front. I find that sometimes I need to just load different datasets and explore them until I get inspiration for a map.

I started with the National Land Cover Dataset (NLCD), which has the potential to be a fun basemap if you can do something with the visually-strong reds they use for urban areas. I sandwiched that between a slope-combined hillshade and a skymodel with strong shadows and got excited about how the mountains looked. I put a roads layer down to help me get my bearings.

Water Flows Downhill
Adding the NHD water basin layer was what gave me my first flash of inspiration for this map. I realized the water basins didn't always line up with my mental map of relationships between areas. It's amazing just how much overland transportation, especially the modern interstate system, hides natural boundaries in our mental maps.



For example, Park City is more related to Ogden, hydrologically speaking, than Salt Lake City. Downtown Park City drains into Silver Creek, which runs into the upper Weber River just below Rockport Reservoir. Kimball Junction and Jeremy Ranch drain into East Canyon and then into the lower Weber River 30 miles downstream. At the top of Parley's summit, the canyons drain down to the Jordan River. Water on the west side of the summit doesn't meet Park City water until the middle of the Great Salt Lake.

If you were to graph out the dendritic drainage structure of the Great Salt Lake Basin, Park City and Kimball Junction would be on hydrologically separate branches despite being physically right next to each other. Parley's Canyon is on completely the opposite side of the trunk, and its branch doesn't meet up until the very end of the graph.



However, my mental relationship map of Park City is almost exclusively focused on I-80 and is completely linear: Salt Lake, Parley's Canyon, Parley's Summit, Jeremy Ranch, Kimball Junction, Park City. Because of how steep the climb up to Parley's Summit is (especially if you've got a 15-year-old four-cylinder station wagon), anything after that is "downhill". The slight elevation difference between Kimball Junction and downtown Park City doesn't even register, but it's enough to send water on two different paths dozens of miles apart.





Deadlines: The Mother of Productivity
Life got busy and months passed before I did anything more with this concept. Finally, at the end of 2019 I saw the announcement that submissions for the 2020 Atlas of Design were due in late January. I thought this map was my best shot, despite still not really having a solid plan. Four weeks to do a map in my spare time? Why not.

Just like photography, a good map needs to have a single focus, a single story it's trying to tell, a single theme it's trying to illuminate. Both photography and cartography are really the art of removing as much extraneous information as possible, similar to the not-really-Einstein quote "make everything as simple as possible, but not simpler." (This also applies to writing, though the length of this post is evidence that I'm much better at simplifying maps than words)


I spent two weeks working on the map with the vague theme of showing the basins. I classified streams, I cleaned up basin boundaries (the NHD doesn't know what to do with the manufactured wetlands in the Jordan River delta), I played with elevation color ramps.

Finding Focus
The NHD flowlines include a couple of major artificial pathways, like the Salt Lake City Aqueduct running from the mouth of Provo Canyon to the mouth of Parley's Canyon. Being an avid user of the Murdock Canal Trail, I knew there were more aqueducts and pipelines that aren't in the NHD. I started hunting down alignments from water conservancy district webpages.

It was after a couple days down this rabbit hole that I realized I was more interested in making a map about all the water works delivering mountain water to the valley cities. This became my new, sharper focus.



I was struck with renewed awe that we move water not just between different branches of the Great Salt Lake Basin (like the Weber-Provo Canal in Kamas) but between the Colorado/Pacific Basin and the Great Basin via the Strawberry and Diamond Fork systems. I wanted to show this, while also showing off the majesty of the Wasatch Front.

So, I guess, in the end, I really have two goals: a) Show the extensive water systems, and b) Show off my hillshading/terrain techniques. I hope that I managed to do b) without impacting a) too much. I can definitely do a different style of map for a), and I've got some ideas for that already.

But for now, such as it is, it is That the Desert May Blossom as the Rose.




Saturday, June 24, 2017

Mental Maps and The Shadows of Human Impact

I like maps. I like to stare at them, try to figure out what their story is. I especially like maps of the physical environment—I've spent hours on Google Maps' terrain view exploring different areas, trying to read the earth, what the bare ground is telling us.

But even with Google Maps, the roads are still there, still distracting us, still saying "look what humans have created! Look at this mighty road we built in this impossible canyon!" So I went to make my own terrain maps, free of the influence of humans.

My first attempt actually ended up telling more of humankind's story than I intended.

Looking for good-but-not-overwhelmingly-detalied elevation data, I downloaded the 5-meter auto-correlated DEM data for the Salt Lake valley from the Utah AGRC. Auto-correlated elevation models are created examining the differences in stereo image pairs (see https://gis.stackexchange.com/a/61993) and thus show various parts of the built environment. What this means is that my attempt to scrub away humankind was beautifully flawed and ended up showing  some really cool artifacts.

Let's start with freeways, because every post about the evils of human influence has to talk about freeways, right? This is an overpass. Even without showing the roads, the massive amount of earthmoving that's been done to raise one high-volume stream of metal, cloth, and human beings over another stream is a little stupefying.

Even old-school grid systems, the darling child of walkability nerds and new urbanists, get in on the act. They're easier to see when they're cut into a hillside and the streets square off the lots to accommodate our discomfort of weird, unordered shapes.

This is a wonderfully disjointed bit of geomorphology. Freeway planners of the 50s and 60s took advantage of a natural stream channel/canyon to build a freeway without having to tear down homes. The steep canyon walls gradually give way to the valley floor, however, and are replaced by the flat bed and smooth, flowing, engineered curves of the Interstate Freeway system.

For all our love of attacking modern human's impact on the environment, let's not forget that something as Utah-Pioneer-'Merica!-ish as farming shows up as well. This is one of the last center-pivot irrigation fields I could find in the valley, though the latest satellite imagery shows it's been dug up in preparation for some sort of development.

File this one in the "What the ...?" department. A look at the satellite imagery shows this massive, angular cut into the hillside was made for... a park. A park?! I'm sure there's a story and reason behind it, but I can't for the life of me figure it out.


————————————————————


But the point of this post isn't to tell this micro story, the story of how we've shaped the earth. No, the story I want to tell is this one.



Look familiar? This is the Salt Lake valley. I've always wondered what it looked like before 1847, when it the only human inhabitants were the Northwestern Shoshone. Like I said above, it's not perfect, but it still gives us a much better picture of what the land beneath our tires looks like.

The human mind is amazing at creating mental maps of areas. We know the routes that are familiar, the topological links between our house, the roads, the freeway, and our office or favorite shopping center. We know the canyons and tall mountains are "east," that Ogden is "north" and Provo is "south." We recognize the Bingham Canyon Mine slag piles as "west."

But this plays tricks on us as well. For years, I always though of going downtown as "going up" somehow. Looking at the elevation color (AKA hypsometric tint), downtown is lower than most of the valley! My mental map doesn't match reality, and it doesn't even match the word "downtown." But the "downtown is up" concept was so engrained in my brain that in Portland I always thought I was going north when I got off the train at Pioneer Square and walked uphill to the PSU campus... on the south end of downtown. But I was going up!

What I like about this map is that except for the few highly-identifiable freeway cuts and raises, you can't use any of your normal mental map clues to figure out where you are. You have to stop thinking about a home, the road, or an arbitrary address grid coordinate, and start thinking about river channels, glacial moraines, and canyons.

After looking at this map in detail, someone told me they couldn't figure out where was where. That's the point.

As Yoda once said, "you must unlearn what you have learned." Let go of your east side vs west side mentality, your downtown vs suburbs bias, your industrial wastelands vs green-grass dreamworld. Release your a priori knowledge, and see what you can find.

Read the story of the valley.


————————————————————

I didn't start intending to write about such abstract ideas as mental maps and such conscientious topics as humankind's impact on the world. No, I wanted to share the discoveries I've made in this map of the place I've lived for over twenty years of my life.

Looking at this map, I realize I barely know it.

I meant to write about the cartographic tools and techniques I used, the thrill of getting something to work after trying half a dozen different ways. Someday I'll write that, and the many other techniques I've discovered in the two years since I first wrote this on my personal blog. But for now, I'll keep exploring.